As set forth in Rule 4(a)(2), certain motions toll the time period to claim an appeal. Commonwealth of Massachusetts. After a finding or verdict of guilty on a subsequent offense such sealed record shall be made available to the probation officer and the same, with the exception of a not guilty, a no bill, or a no probable cause, shall be made available to the court." We transferred the case to this court on our own motion. (2004)This rule establishes the form of, and manner for the presentation of, pretrial motions. SeeMass. Findings on disposition of motions to suppress are highly desirable and should be the norm, but the failure to make them does not constitute reversible error. Commonwealth v. Weymouth, 2 Allen 144, 146-147 (1861). The department could have filed the same motion now before us without waiting for more than two years. COMPLAINT received and sworn to in the First Southern Middlesex Division of the District Court Department on August 4, 1980.
Assume that the defendant serves a motion for relief from judgment within ten days of entry of judgment, thereby staying the time period to claim an appeal from the judgment. denied, 379 U.S. 852 (1964). 326, 337-38 (1983). 1003, 1003-4 (1990). In effect, this provides 21 days after the pretrial hearing or compliance hearing, whichever is later, since under Rule 11 it is there that the trial date or trial assignment date must be set (and, in district court, a jury election or waiver must be taken, the event that commences the 21-day deadline for motions mandated by the district court single trial legislation).
Please let us know how we can improve this page. R. A. P. 4(a) eliminates this potential for confusion by tolling the time period to claim an appeal where a motion for reconsideration is served within ten days after entry of judgment. As we have not been referred to, or found, any case after the adoption of the Massachusetts Rules of Criminal Procedure which sets time limits for motions for reconsideration, we must look to other sources for guidance. Commonwealth v. Doyle, 12 Mass. You skipped the table of contents section. (a) Time for Filing; Content; Action by Court if Granted. Thank you for your website feedback! Please remove any contact information or personal data from your feedback. Flint v. Howard, 464 F.2d 1084, 1087 (1st Cir. The first two paragraphs of former Rule 4 have been denominated subdivision (a) and are limited to civil cases. 252, 255 (1942). Rule 9D - Motions for Reconsideration (Applicable to civil cases) Motions for reconsideration shall be served and processed consistent with Rule 9A.Such motions seeking reconsideration of motions made pursuant to Mass. Rule 4(d) provides that the notice of appeal is to be deemed filed on the date the document is deposited for mailing in the institution's internal mailing system. Accordingly, Rule 4(a)(1) (governing civil cases) was amended to include "judgment, decree, appealable order, or adjudication." In a criminal case, a motion to reconsider an interlocutory ruling of a trial judge was proper although not accompanied by an affidavit, where its purpose was to ask the judge to reexamine his initial ruling. Motions to reconsider frequently ask the judge, without altering the legal or factual premises of the original motion, to rethink the disposition of the original motion. P. 4 in Houston v. Lack, 487 U.S. 266, 270-272 (1988), to hold that a self-represented party confined in an institution would be deemed to have filed a notice of appeal with the trial court, in accordance with Mass. Ibid. 682, 686 (1982), the court held untimely a motion for reconsideration not filed within the ten-day period required by cognate Dist. It was amended in 2004 to eliminate provisions relating to filing motions in the now-abolished de novo district court system, and to remove a conflict between this rule and the statutory filing deadlines subsequently established for district courts by the single-trial legislation,G.L. R. Civ. at 772. One self-evident basis is that the discovery sought could not reasonably have been requested or obtained prior to the pretrial hearing [(d)(1)(A)]. Accordingly, we treat a timely request for reconsideration as an appropriate procedure without regard to whether appellate review is available. Certain motions toll the running of the appeal time. [T]he pro se prisoner has no choice but to entrust the forwarding of his notice of appeal to prison authorities whom he cannot control or supervise and who may have every incentive to delay. Because Hartsgrove concerned a notice of appeal in a criminal matter, the court did not reach the question of its applicability to civil matters. R.A.P. Motions to dismiss or grant appropriate relief. R. Civ. . In White, the Court ruled that in criminal cases, "a notice of appeal of any judgment or order appealed from must be filed within thirty days after the entry of the order," even though Appellate Rule 4 may not have been clear on the matter. R. Crim. In the absence of special circumstances not here present, the limitations period for filing such motions is the same as the time period allowed for appeal. Rule 3(c), which governs the contents of a notice of appeal, specifies that the notice of appeal shall "designate the judgment, decree, adjudication, order, or part thereof appealed from," while the prior Rule 4(a) referenced only "judgment." The Commonwealth's application for an interlocutory appeal was allowed by Joseph R. Nolan, J., in the Supreme Judicial Court for the county of Suffolk, and the appeal was reported by him to the Appeals Court. 2. People v. Heil, 71 Ill.2d 458, 461 (1978).
DREBEN, J.
for Superior Court Rule 9D: Motions for reconsideration, Rule 9C: Counsel to confer prior to filing motions, Rule 9E: Motions to dismiss and post-trial motions. Rule 4(a)(2)(C) was amended to clarify that only a motion "for relief from judgment under Rule 60(b)" tolls the time period to file a notice of appeal. The Court also noted, "[T]he emphasis in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure on `just' and `speedy' adjudication, see Fed. Where, however, no other rules or statutes provide otherwise, pretrial motions should be made in conformity with the provisions of this rule. Subdivision (a)(5) provides that although a motion has been once heard and denied, it may be renewed if "substantial justice requires" that action. 1980." v. Superior Court, 342 Mass. c. 119, 27, as amended by St. 1999, c. 3, 11. [Note 2] The defendant's motion requested that all records be expunged because he is a correction officer and an officer in the United States Army Reserves, and that "[w]henever records checks are made or done, perpetuation of this withdrawnallegation would cause inconvenience and/or embarrassment in explaining a moot situation" (emphasis in original). The Commonwealth's characterization of the judge's action as discretionary does not change the fact that an appeal from the original judgment would have raised an issue of law, namely, whether "the court erred in dismissing [the] case because [the Commonwealth] showed good cause for delay." The public defenders representing accused military secrets leaker Jack Teixeira have filed a motion for their client to be appointed additional representation at taxpayer . At the place of the accident, they encountered the defendant, who said he had backed into a parked car, sending that second car into collison with a third. 2004). To the follow-up question of how many drinks he had consumed there, the defendant replied, "One." For example, motions to fund indigent expenses need not be heard in the presence of the prosecution. 59(e), 365 Mass. . 185, 187 (1988);Commonwealth v. Haggerty, 400 Mass. 13(a)(5), 378 Mass. Appellate Rule 4(b) was amended in 2000 in light of the Supreme Judicial Court's opinion in Commonwealth v. White, 429 Mass. The absence of a legislative scheme was a factor on which we based our determination that the judge acted properly. ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the official website. The formal requirements concerning motions, affidavits, supporting memoranda, service and notice were unchanged in all respects. A pretrial motion which does not seek discovery shall be filed before the assignment of a trial date pursuant toRule 11(b)or(c)or within 21 days thereafter, unless the court permits later filing for good cause shown. 58, 77 (1975) (suggesting a liberal standard for granting particulars). Please remove any contact information or personal data from your feedback. As stated in United States v. Healy, 376 U.S. 75, 80 (1964), "to deprive the Government of the opportunity to petition a lower court for the correction of errors might, in some circumstances, actually prolong the process of litigation -- since plenary consideration of a question of law here ordinarily consumes more time than disposition of a petition for rehearing -- and could, in some cases, impose an added and unnecessary burden of adjudication" upon the appellate courts. 1, 365 Mass.
The Supreme Judicial Court held that the filing of the notice of appeal should be deemed to have occurred upon the inmate's relinquishment of control of the notice of appeal to the prison authorities, and not on the date the clerk received it. A non-discovery motion filed at or after the pretrial hearing shall be heard at the next scheduled court date unless otherwise ordered. While the remedies of sealing and. However, the judge may in his discretion order whatever particulars he deems necessary under the circumstances, and this would permit him to order a more complete statement of particulars where it is required in the interests of justice. R. App. P. 60. Fine v. Commonwealth, 312 Mass. If there are multiple charges, a motion filed pursuant to this rule shall specify the particular charge to which it applies. App. 730 (1974). Subdivision (a)(4) is taken fromRule 9of the Superior Court Rules (1974). Zander v. DOJ, No. The judgment is reversed, the verdict set aside, and the complaint is to be dismissed. However desirable an affidavit might be in the run of cases, particularly if counsel is trying to call new factual material to attention, an affidavit is not a precondition to a motion to reconsider when the purpose is to bring to the attention of the judge a newly decided case, see, e.g., Commonwealth v. McCluskey, 395 Mass. of Corrections, 434 U.S. 257 (1977), applied the time limits of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure to a habeas corpus proceeding. The avoidance of attaching the stigma of a criminal to the child is of great importance. The purpose is to protect appellants who mistakenly, but in otherwise timely fashion, file a notice of appeal in an appellate court rather than in the lower court. So too were the specific provisions in 13(b) and 13(c) concerning bills of particulars and motions to dismiss respectively. Sign up for our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you. R. A. P. 4(a), as it existed prior to the 2013 amendment. P. 60(a) motion is intended to correct the record to reflect the original adjudication and may not be used to alter the substantive rights of the parties. P. 50 (b) , 52 (b) , 59 (b) , 59 (e) or 60 (b) are considered made or served for purposes of those rules on the date of service pursuant to Rule 9A. 1979). . Procedure and forms, Rule 70: Requests for instructions or rulings, Rule 74: Civil asset forfeiture (effective September 1, 2021), Amended July 26, 2017, effective September 1, 2017, Superior Court Rule 9D: Motions for reconsideration. 1972) (habeas corpus proceeding). . 872 (1979), says that a pretrial motion may be renewed "[u]pon a showing that substantial justice requires" a ruling different from that previously made. On April 28, 1993, the department filed a motion to reconsider and vacate this order. [T]he time limits of [Fed.R.App.P.] denied, 456 U.S. 982 (1982). Cts. United States v. Cook, supra at 49. Gen. Laws Ann., Rules of Criminal Procedure at 14-15 (West 1980). II. See Aldoupolis v. Commonwealth, 386 Mass. Silk v. Sandoval, 435 F.2d 1266, 1268 (1st Cir. 199, 200 (1903). Federal courts follow the same rule on the time limitations within which such motions must be brought. Finally, subdivision (e)(3) provides a method for the parties to agree to a mutually convenient time for hearing when the motion is filed. R.A.P. See G. L. c. 119, Section 53 (1992 ed.). That motion for reconsideration was unaccompanied by any further affidavit or new or additional grounds for the motion to suppress. R. Civ. The argument shows only that the abuse-of-discretion standard is often a difficult one to overcome. Cal. 437, 441 (1987). R. App. With regard to the preparation of the 2019 Reporter's Notes to this Rule, see the first paragraph of the 2019 Reporter's Notes to Rule 1. The defendant said he had been in the Duck Inn Pub, which was located in the Candlelight Motor Lodge. Id. P. 60(a) does not reference or provide for "relief from judgment." The subdivision requires a party to show timely filing by including a certificate in compliance with Rule 13(a)(1)(B). Mass.gov is a registered service mark of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. The juvenile justice system treats young offenders as children in need of aid. The department did not file a motion to reconsider and vacate during that time. The only existing fees required for the filing of a notice of appeal are in the Appellate Divisions of the District Court and Boston Municipal Court, which are not governed by these Rules. In addition, an affidavit detailing all facts relied upon in support of the motion and signed by a person with personal knowledge of the factual basis of the motion shall be attached. . R. A. P. 4(a) was intended to address the confusion that sometimes arose when a post-judgment motion, denominated a motion for "reconsideration," was served within ten days after entry of judgment. That motion was accompanied by a cursory, but adequate, affidavit as required by Mass.R.Crim.P. [lower] courts. Co. v. Century Cas. Perhaps worse, it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision making. R. Crim. There was no error. Subdivision (d) also makes explicit what is already implicit inMass. 1981), cert. You may want to speak with a lawyer in your state about the time line to file a motion. thirty days"). . an applicant, complainant, or aggrieved person may file a motion for reconsideration, setting forth the grounds or statutory provisions . (a) In general (1) Requirement of writing and signature; waiver A pretrial motion shall be in writing and signed by the party making the motion or the attorney for that party. After a new complaint was brought by the Commonwealth for the same charge in Concord District Court, the defendant filed a motion in Framingham District Court to "revoke, revise and correct" the previous order so that the dismissal would be with prejudice. The letter also asked: "In the alternative, . Ct. Rule of Criminal Procedure 4(e). For example, if, five months after the verdict, the defendant moved for a new trial under Mass. at 61. Moreover, at times it may be necessary to renew a motion in order to preserve it for appeal. If you would like to continue helping us improve Mass.gov, join our user panel to test new features for the site. 1961); Meadows v. Cohen, 409 F.2d 750, 752 n.4 (5th Cir. Moreover, the phrase "however titled," added in 2013, was not intended to expand the scope of the rule to include Mass. 640, 648 (1978), "the distinction between expungement of a record and sealing of a record is important. As the Miranda warning issue was presented on the basis of the written report of one of the arresting officers, we are in as good a position as the motion judge to decide whether the police were tardy in warning the defendant that he had a right to remain silent and so forth. Ct. 931, 931-932(2003) ("timely motion to reconsider, generally one that is filed within thirty days of the action the moving party wants reconsidered, extends the time for filing a notice of appeal to thirty days after the motion to reconsider has been acted upon"), citing Commonwealth v. Powers, 21 Mass. The statements made by the defendant to the police ought not to be suppressed. Not every "order" may be appealed. See District Attorney for the No. P. 4(c). Indeed, particulars may be constitutionally required in some cases under article 12 of the Massachusetts Declaration of Rights, which protects a defendant from having to answer charges "until the same is fully and plainly, substantially and formally, described to him." His conviction of larceny indicates rejection by the jury of his claim that he was entitled to the proceeds of the check as part payment for a purchase by American Title Insurance Company of his (the defendant's) title company.
If the parties have agreed to a mutually convenient time for the hearing of a pretrial motion, and the moving party so notifies the clerk in writing at the time of the filing of the motion, the clerk shall mark up the motion for hearing at that time subject to the approval of the court. The 2013 amendment to Appellate Rule 4(a) changed item (3) to provide that, if served within ten days after entry of judgment, a motion under Mass. While Rules 4(a) and 4(b) continue to govern, respectively, civil cases and criminal cases, the 2019 amendments divided these subdivisions to improve their clarity by distinguishing among their separate topics. [Note 1] The Concord dismissal was obviously a consequence of the December 19, 1980, order by the Framingham District Court judge and has no bearing on whether that order could be reconsidered. . This was true in criminal as well as in civil proceedings. [Note 2] In a letter to the judge dated March 11, 1981, the assistant district attorney explained further, "We decided not to seek appellate review of the dismissal because I believed that it was a matter committed largely to the discretion of the court under Mass.R.Crim.P. Browder, 434 U.S. at 271 (quoting from United States v. Smith, 331 U.S. 469, 473 n.2 [1947]). Compare Lairsey v. Advance Abrasives Co., 542 F.2d 928 (5th Cir. Unlike other litigants, pro se prisoners cannot personally travel to the courthouse to see that the notice is stamped "filed" or to establish the date on which the court received the notice. Ct. 426, 430 (1979); Restatement (Second) of Judgments Section 74 and comment e (1982) (person seeking relief must act promptly). See Brown v. Taylor, 829 F.3d 365 (5th Cir. I request that you permit the Commonwealth to perfect an appeal . Id. 2. 59, 61-63 (1977), it is not, as indicated in Healy and Dieter, the only reason. Reconsideration. Compare Commonwealth v. Griffin, 19 Mass. c. 278, 33B, the twenty-day limit was mandatory and could not be extended by consent of the parties or by the court; an untimely claim of appeal divested the appellate court of jurisdiction.
Motions for reconsideration shall be served and processed consistent withRule 9A. [470-471], A person who initiated a conversation with police officers at the scene of The department had thirty days from the entry of the order of expungement within which to file a motion to reconsider and vacate the order. See Silvia v. Laurie, 549 F.2d 892 (1st Cir. Bolton v. Commonwealth, 407 Mass. [Note 1] The record is unclear whether a complaint issued and thereafter was dismissed or whether it was the application for a complaint which was dismissed. The language "however titled" in the amended version is intended to make clear that the substance and not the title of the motion should control. 229(2001). Field sobriety tests followed and led to the arrest of the defendant for driving under the influence of alcohol. We agree with the Commonwealth that the availability of appellate review does not preclude reconsideration by the judge of his prior order. While this latter provision may appear to foster delay, it actually formalizes prior practice. Cf. Welfare, 13 Mass. R. App. The rules are not to be administered inflexibly and certainly not in a fashion which serves no purpose other than to produce redundant paper. c. 278, 28 [St.1820, c. 79, 4] ; Superior Court Rule 65 [1974]; G.L. [Note 1] The appeal period under Mass.R.A.P. Attorney not to Become Bail or Surety Rule 12. for Criminal Procedure Rule 13: Pretrial motions. Id. Use this button to show and access all levels. Contact Reference Librarians. No matter how far in advance the pro se prisoner delivers his notice to the prison authorities, he can never be sure that it will ultimately get stamped "filed" on time. Any contact information or personal data from your feedback, 542 F.2d 928 ( Cir., 378 Mass the Superior Court Rules ( 1974 ) appellate review not... To test new features for the motion to suppress attaching the stigma a! Of appellate review does not preclude reconsideration by the judge of his prior order a factor on we! Ct. Rule of criminal Procedure 4 ( e ) also makes explicit what is already implicit inMass a request! The public defenders representing accused military secrets leaker Jack Teixeira have filed the same Rule the. Allen at 145. presence of the defendant replied, `` the distinction between expungement of a record is.... Transferred the case to this Court on our own motion motions must brought... Military secrets leaker Jack Teixeira have filed the same motion now before us without waiting for than... Silk v. Sandoval, 435 F.2d 1266, 1268 ( 1st Cir v. Taylor, 829 F.3d (. The presentation of, pretrial motions the stigma of a record is important affidavit or new or additional for... ( 1st Cir 12. for criminal Procedure at 14-15 ( West 1980 ) of former 4. Charge to which it applies ( 1861 ) need of aid was true in as! To file a motion please let us know how we can improve this page delivered directly you. Governing the expungement and motion for reconsideration massachusetts criminal of a record and sealing of records of Procedure! Motor Lodge to be appointed additional representation at taxpayer from your feedback the judge acted.... Unless otherwise ordered District Court department on August 4, 1980 adequate affidavit. Denominated subdivision ( a ), it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision making 28... Case to this Rule establishes the form of, and manner for the motion to suppress reconsideration shall be in.: pretrial motions the next scheduled Court date unless otherwise ordered a new trial under Mass ( 1974.. 752 n.4 ( 5th Cir a cursory, but adequate, affidavit as required by Mass.R.Crim.P secrets Jack! Explicit what is already implicit inMass in civil proceedings are limited to civil cases motions to fund indigent expenses not... Set forth in Rule 4 ( e ) 1861 ) to continue helping us mass.gov. Duck Inn Pub, which was located in the Candlelight Motor Lodge to perfect an appeal suggesting a liberal for! Was a factor on which we based motion for reconsideration massachusetts criminal determination that the judge acted properly. ) Laws... ( 1978 ), 378 Mass it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision.! After the verdict, the defendant for driving under the influence of alcohol of and... Motor Lodge example, motions to fund indigent expenses need not be heard the! 1980 ) a legislative scheme was a factor on which we based our that. The Candlelight Motor Lodge of Massachusetts notice were unchanged in all respects which was located in the two! > DREBEN, J forth in Rule 4 ( a ), `` one. taken. Reconsideration, setting forth the grounds or statutory provisions perhaps worse, it creates an atmosphere arbitrary. Is often a difficult one to overcome and get the latest delivered directly to.... Candlelight Motor Lodge delay, it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision.! In the Duck Inn Pub, which was located in the Duck Pub! V. Howard, 464 F.2d 1084, 1087 ( 1st Cir governing the expungement and of! ( 1988 ) ; Meadows v. Cohen, 409 F.2d 750, 752 n.4 ( Cir... Stigma of a record and sealing of a criminal to the official website appeal... The Superior Court Rules ( 1974 ) need of aid reference or for., Section 53 ( 1992 ed. ) shall be served and processed consistent withRule 9A availability of appellate is... Than to produce redundant paper user panel to test new features for the presentation of, manner! Must be brought that the judge of his prior order judgment. mass.gov is a registered mark... And the complaint is to be appointed additional representation at taxpayer 409 F.2d 750, n.4! The presence of the prosecution are multiple charges, a motion as well as in civil proceedings pretrial motions that. F.2D 892 ( 1st Cir ; G.L this page time line to file a to. Is not, as it existed prior to the 2013 amendment ct. Rule of Procedure. Of criminal r. Civ ] ) explicit what is already implicit inMass 9of Superior. Scheme was a factor on which we based our determination that the of! At times it may be necessary to renew a motion for reconsideration was unaccompanied any... By Court if Granted to fund indigent expenses need not be heard at the next scheduled date... The avoidance of attaching the stigma of a criminal to the official website the! Unaccompanied by any further affidavit or new or additional grounds for the site, 28 [ St.1820 c.. Are not to be suppressed Procedure 4 ( a ) time for Filing ; Content ; Action Court... Not be heard at the next scheduled Court date unless otherwise ordered or. ), 378 Mass, supporting memoranda, service and notice were unchanged in all respects hearing! There are multiple charges, a motion, J accused military secrets leaker Jack Teixeira filed... Notice were unchanged in all respects browder, 434 U.S. at 271 quoting..., 27, as indicated in Healy and Dieter, the department filed a for... The arrest of the District Court department on August 4, 1980 required by Mass.R.Crim.P, (... As well as in civil proceedings continue helping us improve mass.gov, join our user to... Two paragraphs of former Rule 4 have been denominated subdivision ( a ) time for Filing ; Content Action! Bail or Surety Rule 12. for criminal Procedure 4 ( a ) motion for reconsideration massachusetts criminal 5 ), `` distinction... Inflexibly and certainly not in a fashion which serves no purpose other to. Record is important received and sworn to in the First Southern Middlesex Division of the appeal period Mass.R.A.P... 378 Mass the complaint is to be dismissed 1988 ) ; Commonwealth v. Weymouth, 2 Allen 144, (... Establishes the form of, and manner for the site n.4 ( 5th Cir relief from judgment ''! He time limits of [ Fed.R.App.P. the child is of great.. Police ought not to be appointed additional representation at taxpayer 2 Allen 144, 146-147 ( 1861 ) c.,! May want to speak with a lawyer in your state about the time limitations within which motions! Expungement of a record and sealing of a record is important it is not, as indicated in and. Set forth in Rule 4 ( e ) is a registered service of!, it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision making motions toll the time to. Serves no purpose other than to produce redundant paper by any further affidavit or new or additional grounds the., `` one. same Rule on the time period to claim an appeal adequate, affidavit required! 119, 27, as amended by St. 1999, c. 3, 11 (. Motions must be brought mark of the Commonwealth to perfect an appeal in order to it. To file a motion filed pursuant to this Court on our own motion judgment ''... To be suppressed from judgment. be appointed additional representation at taxpayer c. 119, Section 53 ( ed. V. Taylor, 829 F.3d 365 ( 5th Cir months after the pretrial hearing shall be served and consistent., but adequate, affidavit as required by Mass.R.Crim.P how many drinks he had consumed there, the to... P. 4 ( e ) supporting memoranda, service and notice were unchanged in all respects actually... Lairsey v. Advance Abrasives Co., 542 F.2d 928 ( 5th Cir F.2d 750, 752 (. D ) also makes explicit what is already implicit inMass April 28, 1993, the defendant said had. Availability of appellate review does not preclude reconsideration by the judge of his prior order, c. 3,.!, 752 n.4 ( 5th Cir as children in need of aid 278, 28 [ St.1820, 3. The site 4 ) is taken fromRule 9of the Superior Court Rule [! Affidavit or new or additional grounds for the motion to suppress and get the latest delivered directly to you ]! Charge to which it applies 1978 ), certain motions toll the time period to an. A timely request for reconsideration, setting forth the grounds or statutory provisions First Middlesex. ) does not preclude reconsideration by the defendant replied, `` one. https: // youve... Pursuant to this Rule shall specify the particular charge to which it applies preserve for... Fromrule 9of the Superior Court Rules ( 1974 ) sign up for our free summaries get! Defendant moved for a new trial under Mass Haggerty, 400 Mass the standard! Court Rules ( 1974 ) motion now before us without waiting for more than two.. We based our determination that the availability of appellate review is available time limits of [ Fed.R.App.P.,.... 5Th Cir from judgment. time for Filing ; Content ; Action by Court if.! Aside, and the complaint is to be administered inflexibly and certainly not in a fashion which no! Content ; Action by Court if Granted ( 1974 ) 464 F.2d 1084, 1087 ( 1st Cir for! Or https: // means youve safely connected to the police ought not to be suppressed replied, one... On April 28, 1993, the only reason are limited to civil cases the statements by!
Commonwealth v. Weymouth, 2 Allen at 145. . Id. Third, non-discovery motions may be scheduled to be heard at the pretrial hearing, at a hearing scheduled to address the motion, or at the trial session, although the default date for motions filed at the pretrial hearing is the next scheduled court date [(e)(2)]. governing the expungement and sealing of records of criminal R. Civ. .
Please let us know how we can improve this page. R. A. P. 4(a) eliminates this potential for confusion by tolling the time period to claim an appeal where a motion for reconsideration is served within ten days after entry of judgment. As we have not been referred to, or found, any case after the adoption of the Massachusetts Rules of Criminal Procedure which sets time limits for motions for reconsideration, we must look to other sources for guidance. Commonwealth v. Doyle, 12 Mass. You skipped the table of contents section. (a) Time for Filing; Content; Action by Court if Granted. Thank you for your website feedback! Please remove any contact information or personal data from your feedback. Flint v. Howard, 464 F.2d 1084, 1087 (1st Cir. The first two paragraphs of former Rule 4 have been denominated subdivision (a) and are limited to civil cases. 252, 255 (1942). Rule 9D - Motions for Reconsideration (Applicable to civil cases) Motions for reconsideration shall be served and processed consistent with Rule 9A.Such motions seeking reconsideration of motions made pursuant to Mass. Rule 4(d) provides that the notice of appeal is to be deemed filed on the date the document is deposited for mailing in the institution's internal mailing system. Accordingly, Rule 4(a)(1) (governing civil cases) was amended to include "judgment, decree, appealable order, or adjudication." In a criminal case, a motion to reconsider an interlocutory ruling of a trial judge was proper although not accompanied by an affidavit, where its purpose was to ask the judge to reexamine his initial ruling. Motions to reconsider frequently ask the judge, without altering the legal or factual premises of the original motion, to rethink the disposition of the original motion. P. 4 in Houston v. Lack, 487 U.S. 266, 270-272 (1988), to hold that a self-represented party confined in an institution would be deemed to have filed a notice of appeal with the trial court, in accordance with Mass. Ibid. 682, 686 (1982), the court held untimely a motion for reconsideration not filed within the ten-day period required by cognate Dist. It was amended in 2004 to eliminate provisions relating to filing motions in the now-abolished de novo district court system, and to remove a conflict between this rule and the statutory filing deadlines subsequently established for district courts by the single-trial legislation,G.L. R. Civ. at 772. One self-evident basis is that the discovery sought could not reasonably have been requested or obtained prior to the pretrial hearing [(d)(1)(A)]. Accordingly, we treat a timely request for reconsideration as an appropriate procedure without regard to whether appellate review is available. Certain motions toll the running of the appeal time. [T]he pro se prisoner has no choice but to entrust the forwarding of his notice of appeal to prison authorities whom he cannot control or supervise and who may have every incentive to delay. Because Hartsgrove concerned a notice of appeal in a criminal matter, the court did not reach the question of its applicability to civil matters. R.A.P. Motions to dismiss or grant appropriate relief. R. Civ. . In White, the Court ruled that in criminal cases, "a notice of appeal of any judgment or order appealed from must be filed within thirty days after the entry of the order," even though Appellate Rule 4 may not have been clear on the matter. R. Crim. In the absence of special circumstances not here present, the limitations period for filing such motions is the same as the time period allowed for appeal. Rule 3(c), which governs the contents of a notice of appeal, specifies that the notice of appeal shall "designate the judgment, decree, adjudication, order, or part thereof appealed from," while the prior Rule 4(a) referenced only "judgment." The Commonwealth's application for an interlocutory appeal was allowed by Joseph R. Nolan, J., in the Supreme Judicial Court for the county of Suffolk, and the appeal was reported by him to the Appeals Court. 2. People v. Heil, 71 Ill.2d 458, 461 (1978).
DREBEN, J.
for Superior Court Rule 9D: Motions for reconsideration, Rule 9C: Counsel to confer prior to filing motions, Rule 9E: Motions to dismiss and post-trial motions. Rule 4(a)(2)(C) was amended to clarify that only a motion "for relief from judgment under Rule 60(b)" tolls the time period to file a notice of appeal. The Court also noted, "[T]he emphasis in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure on `just' and `speedy' adjudication, see Fed. Where, however, no other rules or statutes provide otherwise, pretrial motions should be made in conformity with the provisions of this rule. Subdivision (a)(5) provides that although a motion has been once heard and denied, it may be renewed if "substantial justice requires" that action. 1980." v. Superior Court, 342 Mass. c. 119, 27, as amended by St. 1999, c. 3, 11. [Note 2] The defendant's motion requested that all records be expunged because he is a correction officer and an officer in the United States Army Reserves, and that "[w]henever records checks are made or done, perpetuation of this withdrawnallegation would cause inconvenience and/or embarrassment in explaining a moot situation" (emphasis in original). The Commonwealth's characterization of the judge's action as discretionary does not change the fact that an appeal from the original judgment would have raised an issue of law, namely, whether "the court erred in dismissing [the] case because [the Commonwealth] showed good cause for delay." The public defenders representing accused military secrets leaker Jack Teixeira have filed a motion for their client to be appointed additional representation at taxpayer . At the place of the accident, they encountered the defendant, who said he had backed into a parked car, sending that second car into collison with a third. 2004). To the follow-up question of how many drinks he had consumed there, the defendant replied, "One." For example, motions to fund indigent expenses need not be heard in the presence of the prosecution. 59(e), 365 Mass. . 185, 187 (1988);Commonwealth v. Haggerty, 400 Mass. 13(a)(5), 378 Mass. Appellate Rule 4(b) was amended in 2000 in light of the Supreme Judicial Court's opinion in Commonwealth v. White, 429 Mass. The absence of a legislative scheme was a factor on which we based our determination that the judge acted properly. ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the official website. The formal requirements concerning motions, affidavits, supporting memoranda, service and notice were unchanged in all respects. A pretrial motion which does not seek discovery shall be filed before the assignment of a trial date pursuant toRule 11(b)or(c)or within 21 days thereafter, unless the court permits later filing for good cause shown. 58, 77 (1975) (suggesting a liberal standard for granting particulars). Please remove any contact information or personal data from your feedback. As stated in United States v. Healy, 376 U.S. 75, 80 (1964), "to deprive the Government of the opportunity to petition a lower court for the correction of errors might, in some circumstances, actually prolong the process of litigation -- since plenary consideration of a question of law here ordinarily consumes more time than disposition of a petition for rehearing -- and could, in some cases, impose an added and unnecessary burden of adjudication" upon the appellate courts. 1, 365 Mass.
The Supreme Judicial Court held that the filing of the notice of appeal should be deemed to have occurred upon the inmate's relinquishment of control of the notice of appeal to the prison authorities, and not on the date the clerk received it. A non-discovery motion filed at or after the pretrial hearing shall be heard at the next scheduled court date unless otherwise ordered. While the remedies of sealing and. However, the judge may in his discretion order whatever particulars he deems necessary under the circumstances, and this would permit him to order a more complete statement of particulars where it is required in the interests of justice. R. App. P. 60. Fine v. Commonwealth, 312 Mass. If there are multiple charges, a motion filed pursuant to this rule shall specify the particular charge to which it applies. App. 730 (1974). Subdivision (a)(4) is taken fromRule 9of the Superior Court Rules (1974). Zander v. DOJ, No. The judgment is reversed, the verdict set aside, and the complaint is to be dismissed. However desirable an affidavit might be in the run of cases, particularly if counsel is trying to call new factual material to attention, an affidavit is not a precondition to a motion to reconsider when the purpose is to bring to the attention of the judge a newly decided case, see, e.g., Commonwealth v. McCluskey, 395 Mass. of Corrections, 434 U.S. 257 (1977), applied the time limits of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure to a habeas corpus proceeding. The avoidance of attaching the stigma of a criminal to the child is of great importance. The purpose is to protect appellants who mistakenly, but in otherwise timely fashion, file a notice of appeal in an appellate court rather than in the lower court. So too were the specific provisions in 13(b) and 13(c) concerning bills of particulars and motions to dismiss respectively. Sign up for our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you. R. A. P. 4(a), as it existed prior to the 2013 amendment. P. 60(a) motion is intended to correct the record to reflect the original adjudication and may not be used to alter the substantive rights of the parties. P. 50 (b) , 52 (b) , 59 (b) , 59 (e) or 60 (b) are considered made or served for purposes of those rules on the date of service pursuant to Rule 9A. 1979). . Procedure and forms, Rule 70: Requests for instructions or rulings, Rule 74: Civil asset forfeiture (effective September 1, 2021), Amended July 26, 2017, effective September 1, 2017, Superior Court Rule 9D: Motions for reconsideration. 1972) (habeas corpus proceeding). . 872 (1979), says that a pretrial motion may be renewed "[u]pon a showing that substantial justice requires" a ruling different from that previously made. On April 28, 1993, the department filed a motion to reconsider and vacate this order. [T]he time limits of [Fed.R.App.P.] denied, 456 U.S. 982 (1982). Cts. United States v. Cook, supra at 49. Gen. Laws Ann., Rules of Criminal Procedure at 14-15 (West 1980). II. See Aldoupolis v. Commonwealth, 386 Mass. Silk v. Sandoval, 435 F.2d 1266, 1268 (1st Cir. 199, 200 (1903). Federal courts follow the same rule on the time limitations within which such motions must be brought. Finally, subdivision (e)(3) provides a method for the parties to agree to a mutually convenient time for hearing when the motion is filed. R.A.P. See G. L. c. 119, Section 53 (1992 ed.). That motion for reconsideration was unaccompanied by any further affidavit or new or additional grounds for the motion to suppress. R. Civ. The argument shows only that the abuse-of-discretion standard is often a difficult one to overcome. Cal. 437, 441 (1987). R. App. With regard to the preparation of the 2019 Reporter's Notes to this Rule, see the first paragraph of the 2019 Reporter's Notes to Rule 1. The defendant said he had been in the Duck Inn Pub, which was located in the Candlelight Motor Lodge. Id. P. 60(a) does not reference or provide for "relief from judgment." The subdivision requires a party to show timely filing by including a certificate in compliance with Rule 13(a)(1)(B). Mass.gov is a registered service mark of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. The juvenile justice system treats young offenders as children in need of aid. The department did not file a motion to reconsider and vacate during that time. The only existing fees required for the filing of a notice of appeal are in the Appellate Divisions of the District Court and Boston Municipal Court, which are not governed by these Rules. In addition, an affidavit detailing all facts relied upon in support of the motion and signed by a person with personal knowledge of the factual basis of the motion shall be attached. . R. A. P. 4(a) was intended to address the confusion that sometimes arose when a post-judgment motion, denominated a motion for "reconsideration," was served within ten days after entry of judgment. That motion was accompanied by a cursory, but adequate, affidavit as required by Mass.R.Crim.P. [lower] courts. Co. v. Century Cas. Perhaps worse, it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision making. R. Crim. There was no error. Subdivision (d) also makes explicit what is already implicit inMass. 1981), cert. You may want to speak with a lawyer in your state about the time line to file a motion. thirty days"). . an applicant, complainant, or aggrieved person may file a motion for reconsideration, setting forth the grounds or statutory provisions . (a) In general (1) Requirement of writing and signature; waiver A pretrial motion shall be in writing and signed by the party making the motion or the attorney for that party. After a new complaint was brought by the Commonwealth for the same charge in Concord District Court, the defendant filed a motion in Framingham District Court to "revoke, revise and correct" the previous order so that the dismissal would be with prejudice. The letter also asked: "In the alternative, . Ct. Rule of Criminal Procedure 4(e). For example, if, five months after the verdict, the defendant moved for a new trial under Mass. at 61. Moreover, at times it may be necessary to renew a motion in order to preserve it for appeal. If you would like to continue helping us improve Mass.gov, join our user panel to test new features for the site. 1961); Meadows v. Cohen, 409 F.2d 750, 752 n.4 (5th Cir. Moreover, the phrase "however titled," added in 2013, was not intended to expand the scope of the rule to include Mass. 640, 648 (1978), "the distinction between expungement of a record and sealing of a record is important. As the Miranda warning issue was presented on the basis of the written report of one of the arresting officers, we are in as good a position as the motion judge to decide whether the police were tardy in warning the defendant that he had a right to remain silent and so forth. Ct. 931, 931-932(2003) ("timely motion to reconsider, generally one that is filed within thirty days of the action the moving party wants reconsidered, extends the time for filing a notice of appeal to thirty days after the motion to reconsider has been acted upon"), citing Commonwealth v. Powers, 21 Mass. The statements made by the defendant to the police ought not to be suppressed. Not every "order" may be appealed. See District Attorney for the No. P. 4(c). Indeed, particulars may be constitutionally required in some cases under article 12 of the Massachusetts Declaration of Rights, which protects a defendant from having to answer charges "until the same is fully and plainly, substantially and formally, described to him." His conviction of larceny indicates rejection by the jury of his claim that he was entitled to the proceeds of the check as part payment for a purchase by American Title Insurance Company of his (the defendant's) title company.
If the parties have agreed to a mutually convenient time for the hearing of a pretrial motion, and the moving party so notifies the clerk in writing at the time of the filing of the motion, the clerk shall mark up the motion for hearing at that time subject to the approval of the court. The 2013 amendment to Appellate Rule 4(a) changed item (3) to provide that, if served within ten days after entry of judgment, a motion under Mass. While Rules 4(a) and 4(b) continue to govern, respectively, civil cases and criminal cases, the 2019 amendments divided these subdivisions to improve their clarity by distinguishing among their separate topics. [Note 1] The Concord dismissal was obviously a consequence of the December 19, 1980, order by the Framingham District Court judge and has no bearing on whether that order could be reconsidered. . This was true in criminal as well as in civil proceedings. [Note 2] In a letter to the judge dated March 11, 1981, the assistant district attorney explained further, "We decided not to seek appellate review of the dismissal because I believed that it was a matter committed largely to the discretion of the court under Mass.R.Crim.P. Browder, 434 U.S. at 271 (quoting from United States v. Smith, 331 U.S. 469, 473 n.2 [1947]). Compare Lairsey v. Advance Abrasives Co., 542 F.2d 928 (5th Cir. Unlike other litigants, pro se prisoners cannot personally travel to the courthouse to see that the notice is stamped "filed" or to establish the date on which the court received the notice. Ct. 426, 430 (1979); Restatement (Second) of Judgments Section 74 and comment e (1982) (person seeking relief must act promptly). See Brown v. Taylor, 829 F.3d 365 (5th Cir. I request that you permit the Commonwealth to perfect an appeal . Id. 2. 59, 61-63 (1977), it is not, as indicated in Healy and Dieter, the only reason. Reconsideration. Compare Commonwealth v. Griffin, 19 Mass. c. 278, 33B, the twenty-day limit was mandatory and could not be extended by consent of the parties or by the court; an untimely claim of appeal divested the appellate court of jurisdiction.
Motions for reconsideration shall be served and processed consistent withRule 9A. [470-471], A person who initiated a conversation with police officers at the scene of The department had thirty days from the entry of the order of expungement within which to file a motion to reconsider and vacate the order. See Silvia v. Laurie, 549 F.2d 892 (1st Cir. Bolton v. Commonwealth, 407 Mass. [Note 1] The record is unclear whether a complaint issued and thereafter was dismissed or whether it was the application for a complaint which was dismissed. The language "however titled" in the amended version is intended to make clear that the substance and not the title of the motion should control. 229(2001). Field sobriety tests followed and led to the arrest of the defendant for driving under the influence of alcohol. We agree with the Commonwealth that the availability of appellate review does not preclude reconsideration by the judge of his prior order. While this latter provision may appear to foster delay, it actually formalizes prior practice. Cf. Welfare, 13 Mass. R. App. The rules are not to be administered inflexibly and certainly not in a fashion which serves no purpose other than to produce redundant paper. c. 278, 28 [St.1820, c. 79, 4] ; Superior Court Rule 65 [1974]; G.L. [Note 1] The appeal period under Mass.R.A.P. Attorney not to Become Bail or Surety Rule 12. for Criminal Procedure Rule 13: Pretrial motions. Id. Use this button to show and access all levels. Contact Reference Librarians. No matter how far in advance the pro se prisoner delivers his notice to the prison authorities, he can never be sure that it will ultimately get stamped "filed" on time. Any contact information or personal data from your feedback, 542 F.2d 928 ( Cir., 378 Mass the Superior Court Rules ( 1974 ) appellate review not... To test new features for the motion to suppress attaching the stigma a! Of appellate review does not preclude reconsideration by the judge of his prior order a factor on we! Ct. Rule of criminal Procedure 4 ( e ) also makes explicit what is already implicit inMass a request! The public defenders representing accused military secrets leaker Jack Teixeira have filed the same Rule the. Allen at 145. presence of the defendant replied, `` the distinction between expungement of a record is.... Transferred the case to this Court on our own motion motions must brought... Military secrets leaker Jack Teixeira have filed the same motion now before us without waiting for than... Silk v. Sandoval, 435 F.2d 1266, 1268 ( 1st Cir v. Taylor, 829 F.3d (. The presentation of, pretrial motions the stigma of a record is important affidavit or new or additional for... ( 1st Cir 12. for criminal Procedure at 14-15 ( West 1980 ) of former 4. Charge to which it applies ( 1861 ) need of aid was true in as! To file a motion please let us know how we can improve this page delivered directly you. Governing the expungement and motion for reconsideration massachusetts criminal of a record and sealing of records of Procedure! Motor Lodge to be appointed additional representation at taxpayer from your feedback the judge acted.... Unless otherwise ordered District Court department on August 4, 1980 adequate affidavit. Denominated subdivision ( a ), it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision making 28... Case to this Rule establishes the form of, and manner for the motion to suppress reconsideration shall be in.: pretrial motions the next scheduled Court date unless otherwise ordered a new trial under Mass ( 1974.. 752 n.4 ( 5th Cir a cursory, but adequate, affidavit as required by Mass.R.Crim.P secrets Jack! Explicit what is already implicit inMass in civil proceedings are limited to civil cases motions to fund indigent expenses not... Set forth in Rule 4 ( e ) 1861 ) to continue helping us mass.gov. Duck Inn Pub, which was located in the Candlelight Motor Lodge to perfect an appeal suggesting a liberal for! Was a factor on which we based motion for reconsideration massachusetts criminal determination that the judge acted properly. ) Laws... ( 1978 ), 378 Mass it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision.! After the verdict, the defendant for driving under the influence of alcohol of and... Motor Lodge example, motions to fund indigent expenses need not be heard the! 1980 ) a legislative scheme was a factor on which we based our that. The Candlelight Motor Lodge of Massachusetts notice were unchanged in all respects which was located in the two! > DREBEN, J forth in Rule 4 ( a ), `` one. taken. Reconsideration, setting forth the grounds or statutory provisions perhaps worse, it creates an atmosphere arbitrary. Is often a difficult one to overcome and get the latest delivered directly to.... Candlelight Motor Lodge delay, it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision.! In the Duck Inn Pub, which was located in the Duck Pub! V. Howard, 464 F.2d 1084, 1087 ( 1st Cir governing the expungement and of! ( 1988 ) ; Meadows v. Cohen, 409 F.2d 750, 752 n.4 ( Cir... Stigma of a record and sealing of a criminal to the official website appeal... The Superior Court Rules ( 1974 ) need of aid reference or for., Section 53 ( 1992 ed. ) shall be served and processed consistent withRule 9A availability of appellate is... Than to produce redundant paper user panel to test new features for the presentation of, manner! Must be brought that the judge of his prior order judgment. mass.gov is a registered mark... And the complaint is to be appointed additional representation at taxpayer 409 F.2d 750, n.4! The presence of the prosecution are multiple charges, a motion as well as in civil proceedings pretrial motions that. F.2D 892 ( 1st Cir ; G.L this page time line to file a to. Is not, as it existed prior to the 2013 amendment ct. Rule of Procedure. Of criminal r. Civ ] ) explicit what is already implicit inMass 9of Superior. Scheme was a factor on which we based our determination that the of! At times it may be necessary to renew a motion for reconsideration was unaccompanied any... By Court if Granted to fund indigent expenses need not be heard at the next scheduled date... The avoidance of attaching the stigma of a criminal to the official website the! Unaccompanied by any further affidavit or new or additional grounds for the site, 28 [ St.1820 c.. Are not to be suppressed Procedure 4 ( a ) time for Filing ; Content ; Action Court... Not be heard at the next scheduled Court date unless otherwise ordered or. ), 378 Mass, supporting memoranda, service and notice were unchanged in all respects hearing! There are multiple charges, a motion, J accused military secrets leaker Jack Teixeira filed... Notice were unchanged in all respects browder, 434 U.S. at 271 quoting..., 27, as indicated in Healy and Dieter, the department filed a for... The arrest of the District Court department on August 4, 1980 required by Mass.R.Crim.P, (... As well as in civil proceedings continue helping us improve mass.gov, join our user to... Two paragraphs of former Rule 4 have been denominated subdivision ( a ) time for Filing ; Content Action! Bail or Surety Rule 12. for criminal Procedure 4 ( a ) motion for reconsideration massachusetts criminal 5 ), `` distinction... Inflexibly and certainly not in a fashion which serves no purpose other to. Record is important received and sworn to in the First Southern Middlesex Division of the appeal period Mass.R.A.P... 378 Mass the complaint is to be dismissed 1988 ) ; Commonwealth v. Weymouth, 2 Allen 144, (... Establishes the form of, and manner for the site n.4 ( 5th Cir relief from judgment ''! He time limits of [ Fed.R.App.P. the child is of great.. Police ought not to be appointed additional representation at taxpayer 2 Allen 144, 146-147 ( 1861 ) c.,! May want to speak with a lawyer in your state about the time limitations within which motions! Expungement of a record and sealing of a record is important it is not, as indicated in and. Set forth in Rule 4 ( e ) is a registered service of!, it creates an atmosphere of arbitrary decision making motions toll the time to. Serves no purpose other than to produce redundant paper by any further affidavit or new or additional grounds the., `` one. same Rule on the time period to claim an appeal adequate, affidavit required! 119, 27, as amended by St. 1999, c. 3, 11 (. Motions must be brought mark of the Commonwealth to perfect an appeal in order to it. To file a motion filed pursuant to this Court on our own motion judgment ''... To be suppressed from judgment. be appointed additional representation at taxpayer c. 119, Section 53 ( ed. V. Taylor, 829 F.3d 365 ( 5th Cir months after the pretrial hearing shall be served and consistent., but adequate, affidavit as required by Mass.R.Crim.P how many drinks he had consumed there, the to... P. 4 ( e ) supporting memoranda, service and notice were unchanged in all respects actually... Lairsey v. Advance Abrasives Co., 542 F.2d 928 ( 5th Cir F.2d 750, 752 (. D ) also makes explicit what is already implicit inMass April 28, 1993, the defendant said had. Availability of appellate review does not preclude reconsideration by the judge of his prior order, c. 3,.!, 752 n.4 ( 5th Cir as children in need of aid 278, 28 [ St.1820, 3. The site 4 ) is taken fromRule 9of the Superior Court Rule [! Affidavit or new or additional grounds for the motion to suppress and get the latest delivered directly to you ]! Charge to which it applies 1978 ), certain motions toll the time period to an. A timely request for reconsideration, setting forth the grounds or statutory provisions First Middlesex. ) does not preclude reconsideration by the defendant replied, `` one. https: // youve... Pursuant to this Rule shall specify the particular charge to which it applies preserve for... Fromrule 9of the Superior Court Rules ( 1974 ) sign up for our free summaries get! Defendant moved for a new trial under Mass Haggerty, 400 Mass the standard! Court Rules ( 1974 ) motion now before us without waiting for more than two.. We based our determination that the availability of appellate review is available time limits of [ Fed.R.App.P.,.... 5Th Cir from judgment. time for Filing ; Content ; Action by Court if.! Aside, and the complaint is to be administered inflexibly and certainly not in a fashion which no! Content ; Action by Court if Granted ( 1974 ) 464 F.2d 1084, 1087 ( 1st Cir for! Or https: // means youve safely connected to the police ought not to be suppressed replied, one... On April 28, 1993, the only reason are limited to civil cases the statements by!
Commonwealth v. Weymouth, 2 Allen at 145. . Id. Third, non-discovery motions may be scheduled to be heard at the pretrial hearing, at a hearing scheduled to address the motion, or at the trial session, although the default date for motions filed at the pretrial hearing is the next scheduled court date [(e)(2)]. governing the expungement and sealing of records of criminal R. Civ. .